France’s Governance Crisis: Responsibility, Work and Respect for the Law
In his column, Renaud Girard examines what he considers to be a profound crisis of governance in France. Referring to the unrest of 17 October 2026, he argues that the deterioration of public security reflects wider institutional weaknesses.
He identifies several areas of concern: persistent public deficits, declining educational performance, difficulties in maintaining industrial competitiveness, and a widening technological gap with the United States and China.
Drawing on his experience of France during the presidencies of Charles de Gaulle, Georges Pompidou and Valéry Giscard d’Estaing, Girard contrasts the country's former international standing with what he describes as its current decline.
The entire world watched in horror the images of the dark day of 17 October 2026, when the streets of France’s major cities were left at the mercy of looters, and a major town hall, a historic monument, was deliberately set on fire. These foreigners felt more than sadness — many love France because they have visited it or immersed themselves in its culture — they also felt astonishment: how is it that the state which taxes its citizens more heavily than any other in the world is unable to provide them with the bare minimum, namely safety in their streets?
This failure of the state is not limited to security; it can also be seen in the seriously deficit-ridden management of public finances — which means that France now borrows at 144 basis points above Germany and 96 basis points above Portugal —; in public education — where, according to the PISA rankings, the performance of French pupils has plummeted not only in mathematics and science, but also in the crucial category of “reading comprehension”; in research and industry — where we have been unable to halt our decline relative to American and Chinese levels.
It is becoming clear that the entire governance of our country needs to be fundamentally reconsidered.
I pursued my studies under the first three presidents of the Fifth Republic: de Gaulle, Pompidou and Giscard. France was then a safe, hardworking, inventive and respected country. I remember my first trip to the United States in 1979: Americans felt friendship but also respect for France, a country that had been right about Vietnam and was capable of technological innovation (Concorde, the TGV, nuclear power, etc.). Today, Americans still feel friendship for France, but no respect, only compassion, as one feels when witnessing a civilization in the process of dying.
Since 1981, the French state has been infected by the worst disease that can afflict a state: laxity. Forty-five years of laxity in immigration, education, justice and financial management have brought the country to its present situation.
Fortunately, the paths to France’s rebirth do exist. They rest on three simple values that must be restored in our country: responsibility, work and respect for the law.
The spirit of responsibility — which is the opposite of demagoguery — must once again inspire the French people and all their institutions. The state must behave responsibly and therefore balance its revenue and expenditure. No private company would have survived more than five years if it had behaved like the French state.
A responsible state is also one that does not attempt to do everything and anything. It must concentrate on its sovereign functions, those that cannot be entrusted to private initiative in a competitive environment: defence, policing, justice, diplomacy, taxation, customs, energy and fundamental research. But in carrying out its sovereign functions, the state must be uncompromising. It is intolerable that drug trafficking and human trafficking have reached their current levels on French territory.
A responsible state would also be one that dared to reduce France’s extraordinary territorial administrative maze (regions, departments, intermunicipal bodies and municipalities), where no one knows any longer who does what, and where responsibility is systematically limited. The abolition of the residence tax on primary homes, decided in 2017, resulted in municipalities losing their fiscal autonomy. Emmanuel Macron made a strategic mistake by stripping mayors of responsibility.
Responsibility must now become the foremost principle of public education in France. The mammoth education system must be thoroughly decentralized. Headteachers must be able to hire and discipline teachers as they see fit. Healthy competition must be established between fully autonomous schools, whose funding would be provided through education vouchers given to parents. With responsibility, authority will naturally return.
Work, the value that built France from its cathedrals to the Eiffel Tower, must once again become the natural ambition of all citizens. The French are the Europeans who work the least. The 35-hour working week proved fatal to French industry. The ageing of the population mathematically requires that retirement should not be taken before the age of 68, except for particularly arduous jobs.
Dependence on state assistance has discouraged work in France and must be abolished. The state spends 43 billion every year subsidizing housing. Why does the state interfere in our housing? Will we soon demand that it also subsidize our grocer, and then our hairdresser? The nanny state destroys citizens’ sense of responsibility, turning them into dependent individuals, sometimes angry and increasingly demanding. Money, standards of living and qualifications are not rights. They are earned through work.
Finally, respect for the law by everyone must once again become the rule in France. The country cannot tolerate the rule of the street and of activist minorities terrorizing the silent majority who work and pay their taxes. Democracy means respecting the ballot box. It does not mean bringing the country, its secondary schools, businesses and institutions to a standstill through small, mobile and violent squads, the very same kind seen operating in Weimar Germany, which ultimately brought it down.
(Le Figaro international column, Tuesday, 20 October 2026)
Source: Renaud Girard, Le Figaro, International Column, 20 October 2026.